Assessor Resource

FWPTMM5201
Assess product feasibility of designs

Assessment tool

Version 1.0
Issue Date: March 2024


This unit of competency describes the outcomes required to systematically analyse, assess and determine the feasibility of designs for translation into commercially viable production. Work is completed in a forest and wood products factory setting.

The unit applies to Designer (Manufacturing and Engineered Wood Products), Production Manager (Timber Truss & Frame), Designer (Timber Truss and Frame)

No licensing, legislative, regulatory, or certification requirements apply to this unit at the time of publication.

You may want to include more information here about the target group and the purpose of the assessments (eg formative, summative, recognition)



Evidence Required

List the assessment methods to be used and the context and resources required for assessment. Copy and paste the relevant sections from the evidence guide below and then re-write these in plain English.

Elements describe the essential outcomes.

Performance criteria describe the performance needed to demonstrate achievement of the element. Where bold italicised text is used, further information is detailed in the range of conditions.

1. Analyse design objectives

1.1 Identify design purpose and investigate potential market for the product.

1.2 Analyse intended production materials and processes.

2. Determine design assessment criteria

2.1 Establish criteria for assessment of product material options.

2.2 Establish criteria for assessment of product functionality.

2.3 Establish criteria for assessment of production process options considering impact of these on production operations.

2.4 Establish criteria for assessment of safety and potential liability issues.

2.5 Establish criteria for assessment of costs and marketability.

2.6 Determine weighting of scores for each criteria according to importance of issue.

3. Apply the assessment criteria

3.1 Select potential and actual products competing in the market place for comparative purposes.

3.2 Score and grade design against established criteria and record results.

3.3 Score and grade competing products against established criteria and record results.

3.4 Record overall assessment results.

4. Establish feasibility and options

4.1 Analyse assessment results for the design and competing products.

4.2 Reject designs which show poor assessment results and provide no potential for variation.

4.3 Identify designs which show poor assessment results but provide potential options for variation; refer to appropriate personnel.

4.4 Identify designs which satisfy criteria and indicate potential for success.

4.5 Conditionally endorse feasible designs, record conditions and refer to appropriate personnel.

4.6 Record assessment outcomes, maintain and process reports in line with organisational procedures.

A person demonstrating competency in this unit must satisfy all of the elements, performance criteria and foundation skills of this unit. If a specific volume or frequency is not stated below, then evidence must be provided that the following requirements have been performed on at least one occasion:

assess and determine the feasibility of designs for one or more of the following product types:

pallets

crates

trellises

stairs

doors

windows

frames

beams

roof trusses

floor systems

wall frames.

develop a set of assessment criteria and weighted scoring system to include details of:

functionality

safety

environmental impacts of product use

environmental impacts of product production

cost effectiveness of production

marketability

competiveness with similar products on the market

complete a detailed and accurate report for each assessment providing the outcomes.

A person competent in this unit must be able to demonstrate knowledge of:

product feasibility issues, including:

environmental impacts of product use and potential to minimize

functionality – ease of use and application together with its relevance for desired purpose

safety – potential to cause danger to someone or something and potential for litigation against the enterprise

environmental impacts of product production and associated cost to the business

cost effectiveness of production

marketability - potential for sale of the product

competiveness with similar products on the market

sources of information on competitors’ current products and price structure

features, at an in-depth level of understanding, of production processes:

options for materials

construction methods and sequence

types of tools and equipment used for construction

format, content and use of criteria for assessing feasibility of designs:

qualitative and quantitative assessment criteria

scoring systems

weighting of scores according to importance of issue

organisational procedures for:

determining design assessment criteria and completing assessments

communication reporting lines

recording and reporting assessment outcomes.

The following resources must be made available:

computers, keyboards and software programs used to produce assessment documents and reports on assessment outcomes

comprehensive information about the design concept

templates for:

assessment documents

reports on assessment outcomes

relevant personnel for the purposes of communicating information

organisational procedures for design assessment activities.

Competency is to be assessed in the workplace or a simulated environment that accurately reflects performance in a real workplace setting.

Assessor requirements

Assessors must:

hold the appropriate assessor competency standards as outlined in regulations; and

be able to demonstrate vocational competencies at least to the level being assessed; and

be able to demonstrate how they are continuing to develop their VET knowledge and skills as well as maintaining their industry currency and assessor competence.


Submission Requirements

List each assessment task's title, type (eg project, observation/demonstration, essay, assingnment, checklist) and due date here

Assessment task 1: [title]      Due date:

(add new lines for each of the assessment tasks)


Assessment Tasks

Copy and paste from the following data to produce each assessment task. Write these in plain English and spell out how, when and where the task is to be carried out, under what conditions, and what resources are needed. Include guidelines about how well the candidate has to perform a task for it to be judged satisfactory.

Elements describe the essential outcomes.

Performance criteria describe the performance needed to demonstrate achievement of the element. Where bold italicised text is used, further information is detailed in the range of conditions.

1. Analyse design objectives

1.1 Identify design purpose and investigate potential market for the product.

1.2 Analyse intended production materials and processes.

2. Determine design assessment criteria

2.1 Establish criteria for assessment of product material options.

2.2 Establish criteria for assessment of product functionality.

2.3 Establish criteria for assessment of production process options considering impact of these on production operations.

2.4 Establish criteria for assessment of safety and potential liability issues.

2.5 Establish criteria for assessment of costs and marketability.

2.6 Determine weighting of scores for each criteria according to importance of issue.

3. Apply the assessment criteria

3.1 Select potential and actual products competing in the market place for comparative purposes.

3.2 Score and grade design against established criteria and record results.

3.3 Score and grade competing products against established criteria and record results.

3.4 Record overall assessment results.

4. Establish feasibility and options

4.1 Analyse assessment results for the design and competing products.

4.2 Reject designs which show poor assessment results and provide no potential for variation.

4.3 Identify designs which show poor assessment results but provide potential options for variation; refer to appropriate personnel.

4.4 Identify designs which satisfy criteria and indicate potential for success.

4.5 Conditionally endorse feasible designs, record conditions and refer to appropriate personnel.

4.6 Record assessment outcomes, maintain and process reports in line with organisational procedures.

Not Applicable

A person demonstrating competency in this unit must satisfy all of the elements, performance criteria and foundation skills of this unit. If a specific volume or frequency is not stated below, then evidence must be provided that the following requirements have been performed on at least one occasion:

assess and determine the feasibility of designs for one or more of the following product types:

pallets

crates

trellises

stairs

doors

windows

frames

beams

roof trusses

floor systems

wall frames.

develop a set of assessment criteria and weighted scoring system to include details of:

functionality

safety

environmental impacts of product use

environmental impacts of product production

cost effectiveness of production

marketability

competiveness with similar products on the market

complete a detailed and accurate report for each assessment providing the outcomes.

A person competent in this unit must be able to demonstrate knowledge of:

product feasibility issues, including:

environmental impacts of product use and potential to minimize

functionality – ease of use and application together with its relevance for desired purpose

safety – potential to cause danger to someone or something and potential for litigation against the enterprise

environmental impacts of product production and associated cost to the business

cost effectiveness of production

marketability - potential for sale of the product

competiveness with similar products on the market

sources of information on competitors’ current products and price structure

features, at an in-depth level of understanding, of production processes:

options for materials

construction methods and sequence

types of tools and equipment used for construction

format, content and use of criteria for assessing feasibility of designs:

qualitative and quantitative assessment criteria

scoring systems

weighting of scores according to importance of issue

organisational procedures for:

determining design assessment criteria and completing assessments

communication reporting lines

recording and reporting assessment outcomes.

The following resources must be made available:

computers, keyboards and software programs used to produce assessment documents and reports on assessment outcomes

comprehensive information about the design concept

templates for:

assessment documents

reports on assessment outcomes

relevant personnel for the purposes of communicating information

organisational procedures for design assessment activities.

Competency is to be assessed in the workplace or a simulated environment that accurately reflects performance in a real workplace setting.

Assessor requirements

Assessors must:

hold the appropriate assessor competency standards as outlined in regulations; and

be able to demonstrate vocational competencies at least to the level being assessed; and

be able to demonstrate how they are continuing to develop their VET knowledge and skills as well as maintaining their industry currency and assessor competence.

Copy and paste from the following performance criteria to create an observation checklist for each task. When you have finished writing your assessment tool every one of these must have been addressed, preferably several times in a variety of contexts. To ensure this occurs download the assessment matrix for the unit; enter each assessment task as a column header and place check marks against each performance criteria that task addresses.

Observation Checklist

Tasks to be observed according to workplace/college/TAFE policy and procedures, relevant legislation and Codes of Practice Yes No Comments/feedback
Identify design purpose and investigate potential market for the product. 
Analyse intended production materials and processes. 
Establish criteria for assessment of product material options. 
Establish criteria for assessment of product functionality. 
Establish criteria for assessment of production process options considering impact of these on production operations. 
Establish criteria for assessment of safety and potential liability issues. 
Establish criteria for assessment of costs and marketability. 
Determine weighting of scores for each criteria according to importance of issue. 
Select potential and actual products competing in the market place for comparative purposes. 
Score and grade design against established criteria and record results. 
Score and grade competing products against established criteria and record results. 
Record overall assessment results. 
Analyse assessment results for the design and competing products. 
Reject designs which show poor assessment results and provide no potential for variation. 
Identify designs which show poor assessment results but provide potential options for variation; refer to appropriate personnel. 
Identify designs which satisfy criteria and indicate potential for success. 
Conditionally endorse feasible designs, record conditions and refer to appropriate personnel. 
Record assessment outcomes, maintain and process reports in line with organisational procedures. 

Forms

Assessment Cover Sheet

FWPTMM5201 - Assess product feasibility of designs
Assessment task 1: [title]

Student name:

Student ID:

I declare that the assessment tasks submitted for this unit are my own work.

Student signature:

Result: Competent Not yet competent

Feedback to student

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Assessor name:

Signature:

Date:


Assessment Record Sheet

FWPTMM5201 - Assess product feasibility of designs

Student name:

Student ID:

Assessment task 1: [title] Result: Competent Not yet competent

(add lines for each task)

Feedback to student:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Overall assessment result: Competent Not yet competent

Assessor name:

Signature:

Date:

Student signature:

Date: